היפוך הנוהלים הקיימים?

דיון מתוך פורום  רפואה מונעת - סגנון חיים רפואי

01/02/2012 | 21:36 | מאת: רחל

ב-14.1 הביא הפרופסור כמה משפטים בנדון שפורסמו, כביכול, ב-JAMA, מבלי לצטט אותם בצורה מדויקת, כאשר על בסיסם הגיע למסקנות על "היפוך" כביכול של הנהלים המקובלים ברפואה. לשאלותיהם של מספר גולשים בנדון שביקשו ציטוט מדויק, הפרופסור לא השיב. זהו יחס רציני ומכובד לשאלות הקוראים? רחל

רחל "שפורסמו, כביכול, ב-JAMA, מבלי לצטט אותם בצורה מדויקת" נתתי את המקור - לעיון הקוראים הרציניים. בברכה

רחל הנה חלק מהמחקר: Reversals of Established Medical PracticesEvidence to Abandon ShipVinay Prasad, MD; Adam Cifu, MD; John P. A. Ioannidis, MD, DSc [+] Author Affiliations Author Affiliations: Department of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois (Dr Prasad); Department of Medicine, University of Chicago, Chicago (Dr Cifu); and Stanford Prevention Research Center and Departments of Medicine and Health Research and Policy, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California (Dr Ioannidis). Since this article does not have an abstract, we have provided the first 150 words of the full text. KEYWORDS: CLINICAL TRIALS AS TOPIC, DATA INTERPRETATION, STATISTICAL, EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE, GUIDELINES AS TOPIC, OUTCOME ASSESSMENT (HEALTH CARE), PATIENT SAFETY, QUALITY OF HEALTH CARE, UNNECESSARY PROCEDURES. Ideally, good medical practices are replaced by better ones, based on robust comparative trials in which new interventions outperform older ones and establish new standards of care. Often, however, established standards must be abandoned not because a better replacement has been identified but simply because what was thought to be beneficial was not. In these cases, it becomes apparent that clinicians, encouraged by professional societies and guidelines, have been using medications, procedures, or preventive measures in vain. For example, percutaneous coronary intervention performed for stable coronary artery disease and hormone therapy prescribed for postmenopausal women cost billions of dollars and supported the existence of entire specialties for many years. Stable coronary artery disease accounted for 85% of all stenting in the United States at the time of the Clinical Outcomes Utilizing Revascularization and Aggressive Drug Evaluation (COURAGE) trial.1 Large, well-designed randomized trials that tested whether these practices improved major … את התנצלותך - אבקש (דורש!!!) [Full Text of this Article

מנהל פורום רפואה מונעת - סגנון חיים רפואי